VOO vs VTI: 500 Companies or the Entire Market?
How Your Choice Between These Vanguard ETFs Shapes Your Portfolio's Future
When building your investment portfolio, you’ll likely encounter two of Vanguard’s most popular ETFs: VOO and VTI. While seemingly similar at first glance, these funds represent fundamentally different approaches to U.S. equity exposure. VTI offers broader diversification than VOO, which may appeal to investors seeking total market exposure. Let’s explore the key differences and help you decide which aligns better with your investment goals.
The Core Difference: Coverage
The fundamental distinction between these ETFs lies in their coverage of the U.S. stock market:
VOO (Vanguard S&P 500 ETF) tracks the S&P 500 Index, which consists of 500 large-cap U.S. companies. These companies represent approximately 80% of the total U.S. stock market capitalization.
VTI (Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF) tracks the CRSP US Total Market Index, encompassing over 3,800 U.S. companies across all market capitalizations—large, mid, and small.
VTI tracks the CRSP US Total Market Index with 3,600+ stocks, while VOO focuses on the S&P 500’s 500 large-caps. This key difference means that VOO gives you exposure to America’s largest corporations, while VTI provides that same exposure plus thousands of smaller companies.
Expense Ratio and Structure
Both funds share identical expense ratios:
- VOO: 0.03%
- VTI: 0.03%
This means that for every $10,000 invested, you’ll pay just $3 annually in fees—among the lowest in the industry. With identical costs, your choice comes down to investment strategy rather than expense considerations.
Holdings Comparison
The top holdings of both funds overlap significantly but with small differences in weighting:
| Fund | Top Holdings (% of Assets) | Top Sectors |
|---|---|---|
| VOO | Apple (6.76%), Microsoft (6.22%), NVIDIA (5.65%) | Technology (31.71%), Healthcare (10.86%) |
| VTI | Apple (6.19%), Microsoft (5.17%), NVIDIA (4.66%) | Technology (29.41%), Healthcare (11.45%) |
Notice how VTI’s broader holdings slightly dilute the concentration in top stocks. Despite including thousands more companies, VTI’s performance closely tracks VOO because of market-cap weighting—large companies still dominate the index.
Performance Differences
While closely correlated, these funds do show performance variations:
VOO returned 13.70% over the past year, slightly higher than VTI’s 12.90% StockAnalysis. Over the past decade, VOO has averaged annual returns of 12.83%, edging out VTI’s 12.18%.
Why the difference? The past decade has favored large-cap stocks, particularly in the technology sector. However, market leadership doesn’t remain static. During periods when small and mid-cap stocks outperform (like the early 2000s), VTI would likely pull ahead.
The Surprising Correlation
Despite VTI’s 3,800+ holdings, its performance closely tracks VOO’s due to large-cap dominance. This surprises many investors who expect significant divergence given the vast difference in the number of holdings. The reality is that both funds share a correlation of 0.99—they move almost identically through market cycles.
Why? Market capitalization weighting means that despite VTI containing thousands more companies, the largest companies still dominate the fund’s performance. The additional 3,300+ companies in VTI only represent about 20% of the fund’s total value.
Who Should Choose VOO?
VOO might be the better choice if you:
- Prefer stability: The S&P 500 companies tend to be more established and less volatile.
- Want slightly higher dividend yields: Large companies typically pay more dividends.
- Value transparency: The S&P 500 is more frequently discussed in financial media.
- Believe large-caps will continue outperforming: If you expect the current large-cap dominance to continue.
Who Should Choose VTI?
VTI might be the better fit if you:
- Value maximum diversification: Exposure to the entire U.S. market provides the broadest possible domestic equity coverage.
- Believe in small-cap outperformance: Historically, small-caps have outperformed large-caps over very long periods.
- Want a true “set it and forget it” fund: VTI eliminates the need to balance between large, mid, and small-cap allocations.
- Prefer to mirror the total market: For the purest indexing approach, VTI represents the entire market.
Tax Efficiency Considerations
Both funds are structured as ETFs, making them highly tax-efficient compared to mutual funds. While VTI’s higher turnover due to small-cap rebalancing might theoretically create slightly more taxable events, the impact is minimal in practice. For most investors, the tax efficiency difference is negligible.
The Verdict: Two Excellent Choices
The truth is that both VOO and VTI are outstanding investment vehicles with nearly identical expense ratios, strong liquidity, and proven track records. Your choice ultimately depends on your investment philosophy:
- Choose VOO if you want focused large-cap exposure and are comfortable supplementing with other funds for small/mid-cap exposure.
- Choose VTI if you prefer the simplicity of total market coverage in a single fund and potentially higher returns during small-cap rallies.
For most long-term, passive investors, VTI offers the advantage of broader diversification without additional complexity or cost. However, VOO remains an excellent core holding that has slightly outperformed in recent years.
Remember that your asset allocation—the balance between stocks, bonds, and other investments—will have a far greater impact on your portfolio’s performance than choosing between these two excellent ETFs. Whichever you select, stay consistent with your investment plan and maintain a long-term perspective.
Final Thoughts
The VOO vs. VTI debate highlights an important principle in index investing: simplicity often wins. While you could reconstruct VTI by combining VOO with small and mid-cap ETFs, why add complexity when VTI already provides total market exposure in a single fund?
For most investors building a long-term portfolio, either fund will serve you well. The decision comes down to whether you value the focused large-cap approach of VOO or the complete market coverage of VTI. Both represent the passive investing philosophy that has proven successful for millions of investors worldwide.
FAQ
What is VOO? +
VOO is the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF, a fund that tracks the S&P 500 index and provides exposure to 500 of the largest U.S. companies.
What is VTI? +
VTI is the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF that tracks the CRSP US Total Market Index, providing exposure to the entire U.S. equity market with over 3,800 stocks.
Do VOO and VTI have the same expense ratio? +
Yes, both VOO and VTI have the same low expense ratio of 0.03%, making them equally cost-effective options.
Which performs better, VOO or VTI? +
Historically, VOO has slightly outperformed VTI (12.83% vs. 12.18% over 10 years) due to large-cap dominance in recent years. However, VTI may outperform during periods when small-cap stocks rally.
Is VOO or VTI better for long-term investing? +
Both are excellent for long-term investing. VOO may be better for investors seeking large-cap stability, while VTI offers broader market exposure that may perform better during certain market cycles.
How many stocks are in VOO vs. VTI? +
VOO holds approximately 500 stocks (the S&P 500 components), while VTI holds over 3,800 stocks covering the entire U.S. market including small, mid, and large-cap companies.
Are VOO and VTI tax-efficient? +
Yes, both funds are structured as ETFs and are highly tax-efficient with minimal capital gains distributions.
Which fund has higher dividend yields, VOO or VTI? +
VOO typically has a slightly higher dividend yield than VTI, but the difference is minimal (around 0.1-0.2 percentage points).
How correlated are VOO and VTI? +
VOO and VTI have a correlation of 0.99, indicating they move almost identically despite VTI's broader holdings.
Should I invest in both VOO and VTI? +
There's generally no need to invest in both, as they significantly overlap. VTI already contains all of VOO's holdings, plus additional small and mid-cap stocks.
—
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Investing involves risks, including the possible loss of principal. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.
